Causation in Psychoanalysis
نویسنده
چکیده
It has been argued that psychoanalytic and biological theories cannot be integrated because they rely on different epistemological grounds, namely on hermeneutic versus causal explanations, that are inconsistent with each other. Such inconsistency would seriously question the general possibility of neuropsychoanalytic research. Here, I review three important arguments that have been raised in favor of this inconsistency: first, that psychoanalytic attempts to overcome repression aim to go beyond causal relationships; second, that hermeneutic explanations are retrospective and context-dependent and therefore follow a different logic than causal explanations; and third, that only causal hypotheses are falsifiable, while the introspective reasons for one's own behavior are not. I present arguments against each of these statements and show that actually, causal and hermeneutic explanations are, at least in principle, consistent with each other. The challenge for neuropsychoanalytic research remains to find indeed empirical examples of theories which are causal and hermeneutic at the same time.
منابع مشابه
Comparing apples to oranges and making a fruit salad (mixing psychodynamic science and neuroscience): a review of Clay C. Whitehead's "Neo-Psychoanalysis: a paradigm for the 21st century".
Clay C. Whitehead has elegantly announced, with his broad concept of “downward causation” (Campbell, 1974), the arrival of a new paradigm for psychoanalytic understanding, theory, process, and therapeutic action. In such an endeavor, he proposes to review and integrate various threads of thought which have contributed to psychoanalytic metapsychology over the past many centuries. More specifica...
متن کاملGod and Man in Freudian Psychoanalysis: A Critical Examination of Freud’s The Future of an Illusion
In this article, we have attempted to scrutinize Freud’s psychological analysis of man and God. Four different interpretations of this Freudian analysis have been examined hereunder. Freud believes that religion is the outcome of wishful thinking or fear. Freud’s views on the origin of religion have been stated in a detailed fashion in his works on psychoanalysis. His The Future of an Illus...
متن کاملمفهوم علیت در پارادایمهای پزشکی
In this article, we aim to discuss one of the essential concepts of medicine. As a rule, such studies attempt to clarify the philosophical principals of medicine, whereby the act of medic can be regulated based on his clear perceptions of the principles of his knowledge. In this article, we will evaluate the concept of causation in medicine from a philosophical point of view and through histor...
متن کاملThe Effectiveness of Short-Term Psychoanalysis Treatment In Decreasing Psychological Distress and Psychosomatic Symptoms in Patients with Gastrointestinal Dysfunction with Personality Type D
Abstract Introduction: The aim of this study was to evaluate the effectiveness of short-term psychoanalysis on psychological distress and psychosomatic symptoms in patients with gastrointestinal dysfunction with personality type D. Methods: This research was an experimental study with the pre and post-test with a control group and with a two-month follow-up design. The statistical population ...
متن کاملClinician reports of personality pathology of patients beginning and patients ending psychoanalysis.
OBJECTIVES The purpose of this work was to use a clinician Q-sort procedure to describe the personality pathology and adaptive functioning of patients beginning and ending psychoanalysis. DESIGN With a cross-sectional design, we compared a group of patients beginning and a group of patients ending psychoanalysis. METHODS Twenty-six psychoanalysts described a patient beginning psychoanalysis...
متن کامل